UNCURIOUS · 01

A Note Before We Begin

Prologue

Someone close to me read an early draft of this and was ambivalent about it. I've been thinking about why ever since, because that ambivalence isn't unique to her — I think it reflects something many Jewish people feel.

There is a concept, rooted in our tradition, that Esav hates his brother — that antisemitism is not circumstantial but structural, woven into the fabric of the world we live in. That it has always been here and always will be. And even from a purely non-religious standpoint, after thousands of years of this, the argument for futility is not a stupid one. We have fought this battle generation after generation. It keeps coming back. Why spend the energy?

I disagree. Not because I think antisemitism can be eradicated — I don't know that it can. But because it is not static. It rises and it falls. It is dynamic. And if it can rise — as it is rising right now, visibly, aggressively, in ways I have not seen in my lifetime — then it is equally rational to believe it can fall. The direction it moves is not fixed. Which means what we do matters.

We do not have the luxury of sitting this one out. There are too few of us to fight it one to one, to defend ourselves violently if it comes to that — and it increasingly feels like that is where things are heading, in Israel and in the diaspora. Violence as a defense of our right to exist is a losing strategy in the long run. We have had the relative luxury of the last few decades, of a world where antisemitism felt like a historical artifact rather than a present threat. That world is gone. For the sake of our children we need to fight the battle of ideas now, before it gets too late. And we know — we know with terrible clarity — what too late looks like.

So yes — the most important things remain: knowing who we are, knowing our history, staying united as a people, keeping our families together, doing our work in the world because parnasa is not separate from identity, it is part of it. Those things come first. But we also need to fight the battle of ideas. That is what this project is for. To make it easier to keep Jewish people safe. To give anyone who wants to make that argument the tools to make it well.

My wife has a different view on all of this. Her argument is simple and not without merit: stop fighting the haters. They outnumber us. They always will. They fight us because their lives are full of pain and they need an easy answer, and we're the answer that's always available. But here's the thing — we're not actually the answer. We never were. If we disappeared tomorrow their problems would remain, probably worse, because Jewish people have contributed positively to every society we've ever lived in. So why dignify them with a response? Go about your life. Let the losers seethe.

I understood the argument. For a long time I even tried to live by it. The problem is that for twenty years I watched the hatred grow while we looked away. And I watched who was left standing on the front lines, and I didn't like what I saw.

The people willing to show up and fight were often not the people I wanted to be standing next to. They were the far-right contingent, the "Kahane was right" crowd, people whose hatred of Muslims was as shallow and unexamined as the hatred directed at us — ideology that could fit on the back of a matchbook. They were fighting hate with hate and calling it solidarity. I didn't want any part of it.

So I stepped back. And I felt like a loser for doing it, and I felt like a loser for having cared in the first place, because the leaders of Jewish culture and industry and thought were nowhere to be found. It was the part-time workers and the Thursday afternoon counter-protesters who had nothing else to do. It was not the Jews I knew. It was not who we are.

And then October 7 happened.

And something shifted that I don't think has shifted back. We have a way of describing the Jews who came closer to their Yiddishkeit after that morning — those who looked into the abyss and felt the pull toward their people rather than away from them. Many of us did exactly that. We are lumps of coal: under pressure, we don't break. We get harder. We get brighter.

Years later, there are still Jews who want to help but don't know how. Who feel the urgency but not the direction. Who are waiting for someone else to make the argument clearly enough that they can use it.

This is for them. This is to strengthen their resolve, to give them a picture of who we are and why we're here — and to say plainly, for anyone who needs to hear it: the hatred directed at us is not only wrong. It is stupid. Spectacularly, embarrassingly, historically stupid. And that needs to be said out loud.

This one is for the ambivalent ones too.


On love

I approach this subject out of love. Love for my family above all. Love for my people. And love for all people, including the ones whose cause is pointed at us like a weapon.

I have watched the Palestinian people from a distance the way you watch a car on television driving toward a cliff. You can see what's coming. They can't. Or won't. And you want to scream at them to swerve, but they can't hear you, and it's all happening in slow motion. It is such a waste.

Their suffering is real. Their hopelessness and anger and frustration are real. The fact that it is aimed at my people does not make it less painful to witness — if anything it makes it more so, because I know it doesn't have to be this way.

I have been an advocate for Israel for about twelve years specifically, online and in conversation — but really my whole life. My mother is Israeli. I've been to Israel and I love the people — and yes, they are not like us diaspora Jews. They are, if anything, the 2.0 version of us. More direct, less apologetic, already living the answer to the question the rest of us are still asking — one I'll come back to.

But my specific online advocacy started when Facebook had its own 2.0 moment, when the news feed became powerful. Suddenly, instead of finding out that Darren from 10th grade Chemistry — that shnorer — actually got himself a hottie for a wife, who knew, we were now interacting with complete strangers from all over the world about culture, politics and the news cycle. And it was fascinating. That is, of course, until the subject of Israel came up.

Suddenly I was exposed to the most vile opinions about Jews I had ever encountered in real time. I knew antisemitism existed — I learned about the Holocaust in Hebrew school, I had a rational understanding of history — but I had also grown up believing that the internet, the world's information at everyone's fingertips, liberal democratic values gaining ground — there was no way this toxicity could gain real traction.

I monitored it closely. You could ask my wife, who had two babies at home and a husband whose face was attached to his phone. It genuinely fucked with me.

My second daughter had just been born. I had a wife, a business where I worked 60+ hours a week, and a house. And all of a sudden I had to actually worry about — antisemitism?? In 2012? The things people were saying online were straight out of Der Stürmer — now arriving through a screen.

I grew up knowing about the conflict in the way Canadian Jewish kids know things — at a safe distance with emotional proximity. I knew the Arab street had lobbied Pepsi to boycott Israel. I remembered going to Israel at four years old and my mother telling me not to pick up anything off the ground because it could be a bomb planted by an Arab. That's a fairly significant mind-expansion for a Canadian kid. It lodged somewhere and never left.

Because it wasn't a flippant comment my mother was making. She grew up in Israel. She experienced what it was like to live in constant awareness of terrorist threat — a bombing, a stabbing, a shooting, a kidnapping — that could come at any time, in any city, at any market or bus stop or playground, designed specifically to make Jews feel unsafe in their own country. I will go into detail elsewhere in this project about exactly how many such actions I'm talking about, and what they looked like up close. Gruesome stuff. The kind of stuff that never makes international headlines because a dead Israeli Jew is not the story the world wants to tell.

And to think — all of this, decade after decade, because the Zionists just don't want Palestinians to be free. That's the story. That's what we're supposed to believe.

So I became obsessed with getting to the bottom of this farshtikene conflict. And I went in with genuine openness — if we are at fault, so be it. We make amends, we apologize for whatever they think we did, and yalla, peace. These people love their children. They want peace. It's only rational.

What I kept encountering was a version of peace that required Israelis to surrender something no people should have to surrender: the right to govern and defend themselves. That is the demand I am arguing with. It is not what every Palestinian believes, and I don't want the distinction to disappear.


To my genteel Gentile reader

Let me ask you something directly. When you saw — on this new thing called social media, where the entire world suddenly had a voice and an audience — that one tiny group, a group that has suffered immeasurably throughout recorded history, was being openly blamed for all the world's troubles, what did you think? Not abstractly. What did you think if you had children? If you had daughters who were going to grow up in a world where people with massive platforms said these things openly, without embarrassment, without consequence — things that in my lifetime were only whispered by the obviously unhinged — what would you do?

How much of that can a person absorb before it stops being a political debate and starts being something else entirely?

That is where I was. That is where a lot of us were. And that is why I'm asking you — whoever you are reading this — to be curious. Not to agree with me. To ask questions.

Specifically: if the answers you're getting are too easy, if one small ancient people can be blamed cleanly for everything wrong in the world, that should give you pause. Easy answers to complex questions are almost always wrong. And when the easy answer is always the same people's fault, you're not looking at analysis. You're looking at something much older.

← Contents