UNCURIOUS · 07
Truth, Politics, and Coming Home
Netanyahu and the Narrative's Convenient Target
The Narrative loves to make Netanyahu the villain — as if the conflict began with him, as if removing him would end it, as if the millions of Israelis who keep electing him are victims of a con rather than adults with a coherent worldview.
The argument predates Netanyahu by a century. Whoever sat in the Prime Minister's chair — Labor, Likud, centrist, right-wing — the Narrative would have found a way to blame them. Rabin was a warmonger before he was a martyr. Barak offered Palestinians nearly everything at Camp David and was called an occupier when they said no. Sharon withdrew from Gaza completely, dismantled Israeli settlements, forcibly removed Jewish families from their homes — and was called a war criminal. The problem was never the person. The problem, for the Narrative, is the existence of the Jewish state. The Prime Minister is just the current face to put on the accusation.
A European surname does not settle a Jewish family's history or relationship to Israel. Jews carried names shaped by the societies in which they lived, and some adopted Hebrew names when they returned. Treating a name as a DNA test for belonging is a clever-sounding shortcut. It is still a shortcut.
And Israeli voters are not a single European bloc. Jews with roots in Iraq, Yemen, Morocco, Egypt, Iran, Libya, and Syria are central to Israeli society and politics. Their families' experiences of minority life, persecution, migration, and sometimes expulsion help shape the country's arguments. They do not all vote alike. They do deserve to be heard as adults with reasons, not props in someone else's story.
This is the fact the uncurious gloss over entirely. They see Israeli elections and assume the voters are brainwashed or irrelevant. They never ask why the people with the most direct experience of living among Arab populations keep voting for the hardliners. The answer, if you bothered to ask, would tell you more about this conflict than a hundred op-eds in The Guardian.
A Note on Truth — And Where This project Stands
I believe G-d is truth. And as a Jewish person I believe we should not be afraid of the truth — because G-d has our best interest at heart. Not just for the Jews. For everyone.
This project is not a propaganda vehicle. It is the truth as I see it. And because of that, there are things I believe Israel can do better. There are positions within the Zionist camp I don't agree with tactically, and I want to name them — because intellectual honesty is the whole point of this project. If I only tell you the parts that flatter us, I am doing exactly what the Narrative does. And I refuse to do that.
The ever-increasing Israeli movement that has given up on the two-state solution and now believes Israel must control the land from the river to the sea — I understand where it comes from. Decades of offering concessions and peace only to be answered with violence, missiles, car rammings, and bus bombings have scarred the Israeli public deeply. They have finally started to believe the Palestinians when they chant from the river to the sea. They have given up on the idea that Palestinian leadership will ever choose their children's future over their hatred of Jewish sovereignty. That disillusionment is rational. It is earned. It is also, I believe, a strategic and moral dead end.
This political current has both pragmatic and messianic elements. The messianic wing is led by Bezalel Smotrich and Itamar Ben Gvir — religious nationalist politicians who believe Israeli sovereignty over all of biblical Israel is not just a political goal but a divine mandate. Their ideology is real, their influence is growing, and I think it is dangerous — not because Jewish connection to Judea and Samaria isn't real and ancient, it absolutely is — but because subjugating another people indefinitely is not a sustainable moral position for a democratic Jewish state, and because the international and strategic costs of that path are ones Israel cannot afford to pay alone.
Israel used to be a very secular country. To understand how it got here, you have to go back to the beginning.
The Aliyot — Coming Home in Waves
The founding of Israel didn't happen in a single moment. It happened in waves — waves of Jewish immigration called aliyah, which means to ascend or climb. When we go to Israel we rise up, spiritually and literally, with Jerusalem sitting on a mountain. Each wave brought different Jews from different places for different reasons, and together they built something that had never existed before.
Before the formal waves, there was already a continuous Jewish presence in Palestine — concentrated in the holy cities of Jerusalem, Tzfat, Tiberias, and Hebron. Jews had never fully left. War, displacement, and migration transformed Jewish life over centuries, but Jewish presence in the land did not simply end. The aliyot joined and expanded what was already there.
The First Aliyah (1882–1903) — The Farmers. Russian Jews belonging to Hovevei Zion — Lovers of Zion — fleeing the anti-Jewish violence that followed the 1881 assassination of Tsar Alexander II. Approximately 25,000–35,000 people. Alexander II had been relatively liberal — he'd relaxed some restrictions on Jews, allowed certain educated Jews to live outside the Pale of Settlement, the western strip of the Russian Empire where 95% of Russian Jews were legally confined. Then he was assassinated. One of the conspirators had Jewish origins. False rumors spread across Russia that Jews were responsible, and mobs attacked Jewish communities in more than 200 cities and towns. His son, Tsar Alexander III, took over with a fierce hatred of the Jews — enacted the May Laws restricting Jewish life further and gave mob violence the unofficial sanction of state indifference. The pogroms could last for days. Homes burned. Synagogues destroyed. Between 1881 and the First World War, an estimated 2.5 million Jews left Russia. Most went to America. The ones who went to Palestine were the ideological true believers — people who had decided that building a new life in someone else's country was not the answer. They established the first agricultural colonies — Rishon LeZion, Rosh Pina, Zichron Ya'akov. They arrived to malarial swamps and Ottoman bureaucracy. They stayed anyway. Nachshon into the sea.
The Second Aliyah (1904–1914) — The Socialists. Approximately 40,000 Russian and Polish Jews, shaped by both Zionist ideology and labor movement politics. David Ben-Gurion arrived in this wave. They established the kibbutz. They helped expand the revival of Hebrew as an everyday spoken language. They built the self-defense organizations and labor institutions that would become the skeleton of a state.
The Third Aliyah (1919–1923) — The Post-War Idealists. Approximately 40,000 Eastern European Jews arriving after the First World War and the Balfour Declaration — Britain's formal endorsement of a Jewish homeland in Palestine. Golda Meir made aliyah in this period, from America. They strengthened the kibbutz movement and built the agricultural economy.
The Fourth Aliyah (1924–1929) — The Middle Class. Approximately 67,000 middle-class Polish Jews fleeing antisemitism and economic restrictions. More urban, less ideological. Tel Aviv grew significantly. Small businesses, restaurants, hotels, the beginnings of a civilian economy.
The Fifth Aliyah (1929–1939) — The Professionals. Nearly 250,000 Jews fleeing the Nazi rise to power — doctors, lawyers, architects, musicians, intellectuals. They built the cultural and professional infrastructure. The Palestine Symphony Orchestra was founded in 1936 specifically to give Jewish musicians fleeing the Reich somewhere to play. It became the Israel Philharmonic. The British severely restricted immigration during this period through the White Papers — closing the door on Jewish refugees at the precise moment the door mattered most.
After 1948 came a vast ingathering, including Jews from Iraq, Yemen, Egypt, Morocco, Libya, Iran, and Syria. The circumstances differed by country: persecution and expulsions, fear, political upheaval, and the pull of a Jewish state. Many arrived with very little. Tent cities and discrimination were part of the Israeli story too. They stayed. They built. Their families changed the country.
Israel's religious and political changes cannot be reduced to one migration wave. Early Zionism contained secular and religious currents; so did the communities that arrived later. The 1967 war gave powerful new momentum to religious nationalism and the settlement movement. Demography, security, class, faith, and party politics all shaped what followed.
Smotrich and Ben Gvir are not an aberration. They are the product of a specific historical and demographic trajectory that started in 1967 and has been building ever since. Understanding that trajectory is what lets you critique them honestly without dismissing the legitimate impulses underneath their politics.
The word uncurious is doing real work in this project so it deserves an explanation.
I feel a slow erosion of institutional trust. Governments, banks, media, universities: too many people no longer believe that the institutions asking for confidence have earned it. During COVID, I felt that mistrust sharpen. Questions too often became tests of loyalty. I am describing the feeling that took hold, not claiming that every restriction or public-health decision was a conspiracy.
Into that vacuum of institutional trust came the oldest available answer.
The wealth gap is widening. Young people cannot enter the real estate market — the primary vehicle for building generational wealth in the Western world. They can afford a phone, a laptop, a new car, UberEats, Netflix — all depreciating assets, all lifestyle, none of it equity. Social media sells them the performance of wealth without the substance of it. And somewhere in the gap between what they were promised and what they can actually build, they need an explanation. Someone to blame. Something to point at.
Into that anger comes an explanation ready-made: Jewish power. The old conspiracy makes a chaotic world feel organised. Social media can deliver it with speed and emotional force. Being satisfying is not the same thing as being true.
Here is what nobody is saying clearly: the left and the right have converged on antisemitism from completely opposite directions and too many people excuse it on their own side.
Antisemitic rhetoric on parts of the left targets Israel because it fits the colonial oppressor narrative. Israel is Western, powerful, American-backed — everything the progressive framework has identified as the enemy. It doesn't matter that half of Israeli Jews are from the Middle East and North Africa, or that Israel is a multiethnic democracy in a region of authoritarian states. The frame was set before the facts arrived.
Antisemitic rhetoric on parts of the right targets Israel because — in a different version of the same paranoia — it sees Jewish influence as part of the globalist establishment eroding national sovereignty, traditional values, and cultural homogeneity. The cosmopolitan identity that doesn't fit neatly into nationalist categories feeds a different but equally ancient accusation.
Same Jew. Opposite accusation. Neither side curious enough to notice they've ended up in the same place as their supposed enemy.
And when you point this out to them, they don't ask why. They move to the next accusation. Because the answer to why would require them to look inward — at their own resentments, their own need for a simple explanation to a complicated life — and that is the one thing the uncurious will not do.
Antisemitism has always been the refuge of people who needed the world to make sense and found a shortcut. What's new is the scale, the speed, and the algorithmic infrastructure designed to make the shortcut feel like a discovery.