Ideas have consequences

Edward Said's Orientalism gave influential language to the relationship between Western scholarship and imperial power. My argument is with what happens when a framework becomes the only permitted way to see a people.

Born in Jerusalem in 1935, Palestinian by origin, American by education, professor of literature at Columbia University. In 1978 he published Orientalism — a book that argued the entire Western scholarly tradition of studying the Middle East was not neutral analysis but a tool of imperial domination. That Western knowledge about the Arab world was constructed to justify Arab subjugation. That the very act of Western people describing non-Western people was an act of power, not understanding.

It was a serious and genuinely interesting argument. It was also a weapon.

Because once you accept Said's framework — that Western knowledge about the East is inherently colonial — you have a tool that can be applied to anything. Including Israel. Suddenly Israel isn't a people returning to their ancestral homeland after two thousand years of exile. It's a Western colonial project imposed on indigenous people. The Jews aren't the indigenous people. They're the colonizers. The evidence doesn't matter, because the evidence was produced by the colonial framework. You can't trust it.

When that framework is applied to Jews as though we were simply Europeans abroad, something essential disappears: our own memory, our own vulnerability, and our own relationship to the land. That is the objection I want readers to consider.

A powerful idea can illuminate and obscure. Once it becomes a reflex, it can stop being a question and start being an answer supplied in advance. That is the danger I see.

Ideas travel through universities, journalism, activism, and politics. That does not make every person who uses a similar vocabulary part of one coordinated campaign. It means we should examine the vocabulary and ask what it lets us see—and what it prevents us from seeing.

Apply that test to campus organisations too. What do they actually advocate? Do they distinguish Israeli policy from Jewish identity? Do they recognise the humanity and rights of both peoples? A familiar slogan is not an answer to those questions.

Funding deserves scrutiny. But named people, grants, salaries, and institutional relationships require documentation. I will not answer a conspiracy about Jewish money by constructing a different conspiracy out of insinuations. Show the transaction and the connection being alleged.

Sincerity is not proof either. A true believer can be wrong. So can I. The standard has to be the claim and the evidence, not how deeply someone feels it.

The Loyalty Question

This is the one that has to be addressed directly. It goes like this: how can Americans trust Jews if Jews love Israel more than America? If Jewish money flows to Israeli lobbying, if Jewish organizations push American foreign policy toward Israel, isn't that a conflict of interest at best and a fifth column at worst?

It is a legitimate-sounding question that can conceal an old presumption: that a Jew's belonging is conditional. Other diaspora communities also face suspicion. That does not make this version less recognisable.

The accusation helped convict Dreyfus in France. It has followed Jews across borders and political systems. An attachment to family and history abroad is not, by itself, evidence of disloyalty at home.

But here's the more direct answer: American Jews support Israel for the same reason Cuban-Americans supported regime change in Cuba, the same reason Irish-Americans sent money to Ireland during the Troubles, the same reason Greek-Americans lobbied against the Turkish invasion of Cyprus. Because they have family there. Because they have history there. Because when a people that has spent two thousand years being expelled from places finally has one place that cannot expel them, that place matters.

The test should be the same for everyone: assess a person's conduct. Criticise a lobbying organisation's policies. Investigate a specific conflict of interest. Do not turn being Jewish into the conflict of interest.

If your argument requires me to prove that I am a loyal citizen before I may speak, we are already having a different conversation.

Here is something I'll admit that most pro-Israel voices won't: the campaign against Israel is smart. Genuinely, tactically smart. And if we don't acknowledge that, we can't understand why it's working.

Start with the language. They took our word — Zionism, a Jewish term for Jewish self-determination in our ancestral homeland — and turned it into a slur. They took antisemitism and defused it by arguing that Arabs are Semites too, so how can they be antisemitic? They took hasbara — a Hebrew word simply meaning explanation or public diplomacy — and weaponized it so that any Jewish attempt to make a rational argument is pre-labeled as propaganda before the first word is heard. You don't have to refute an argument you've already branded as hasbara. You just say the word and move on.

And that's exactly what they do. Accuse, accuse, accuse — and when we explain, they don't acknowledge the response. They don't engage with it. They don't say "that's a fair point but here's why I still disagree." They move to the next accusation. And the uncurious, watching the exchange, don't notice the pattern. They see Israel always on defense, always explaining, always justifying — and they conclude that where there's smoke there's fire. The game is rigged before it starts. It's not logic. It's choreography. A Gish Gallop dressed up as moral outrage.

The genius of it is that it turns our greatest strength — our ability to argue, to reason, to construct a case — into a liability. The more precisely we explain, the more it looks like spin. The more evidence we present, the more it looks like deflection. Every rebuttal becomes proof of guilt to someone who's already decided.

I can imagine a strategist discovering how useful that trap would be. But imagining the meeting is not evidence that it happened. The pattern I want to examine is the one in front of us: an accusation designed so that every possible answer counts against the accused.

Here's what the uncurious don't understand about their own campaign. They think they're running two operations simultaneously. The first is aimed at us: convince the Jews they can't win, that they're on the wrong side of history, that the weight of world opinion makes their position untenable. The second is aimed at everyone else: build enough pressure that the international community is forced to act. It's a pincer movement and on paper it looks effective.

What they miss is what the first operation actually does to us. Pressure doesn't dilute Jewish identity. It concentrates it. It always has — this is not a new finding, we have several thousand years of data on this point. The Jews who peel away under that kind of pressure were already halfway out the door. They were looking for an exit and the campaign handed them one with a moral wrapper around it. Fine. Let them go. What gets left behind is harder, more certain, more awake. The antisemite has never understood that he is doing our work for us. Every time he makes the stakes clear, the Jews who feel it in their bones draw closer together and the ones who don't find somewhere else to be. You end up with a smaller, more concentrated, more purposeful people. Which is, in a dark way, exactly what we've always been.

October 7 did this at scale and at speed. The sorting that might have taken a generation happened in a weekend. The Jews who felt it — felt it in the way you feel something that rewrites you — came forward. Some of them hadn't been inside a synagogue in years. Some of them had spent the better part of a decade carefully constructing a progressive identity that had no room for Zionism. That morning broke the construction open and what was underneath was older than any political identity. It was the bone thing. You either have it or you don't. And now everyone knows which side they're on.

That is not a win for the uncurious. That is their worst outcome. A concentrated, awake, unapologetic Jewish people who have stopped performing for audiences that were never going to applaud anyway. They meant to break us. They got us.

Sources and context

Holocaust Memorial Museum: the Protocols fabrication
Nostra aetate, section 4
ICJ: summary of the July 2024 advisory opinion

← Contents

Previous: The Conflict Beneath the Conflict

Next: Watch & Sources →

06 / The stories we’re told / A growing reference

Old accusations.
New packaging.

The names change. The machinery is familiar: take a person, erase the person, and replace them with “the Jews.” Here is a guide to recognising the pattern, with sources you can check.

This is a growing catalogue, not a claim to list every version. The headings below identify false accusations and prejudices, not facts about Jews. Open a card for the explanation and evidence.

30 reference entries. Search narrows the catalogue below.

Power & conspiracy

A secret Jewish world government

The Protocols of the Elders of Zion is a fabrication, not a leaked plan. Its conspiracy turns millions of different people into one imaginary puppet-master.

Source: USHMM · The Protocols

Back to categories ↑
Jews control the news and entertainment

A Jewish owner, journalist or artist is not evidence of collective Jewish control. Criticise a company’s conduct; a surname is not proof of a conspiracy.

Source: ADL · Power

Back to categories ↑
The Rothschilds control everything

A real banking family becomes an all-purpose explanation for finance, war and disaster. The leap from a documented business to omnipotent ethnic control is the conspiracy.

Source: ADL · Power

Back to categories ↑
Every Jew is rich

The stereotype erases economic diversity and makes ordinary Jews targets for someone else’s fantasy about wealth. ADL documents its deadly role in the kidnapping of Ilan Halimi.

Source: ADL · Greed

Back to categories ↑
Greed is a Jewish trait

A financial act is attributed to ancestry rather than an individual. That move turns an economic complaint into prejudice against an entire people.

Source: ADL · Greed

Back to categories ↑
Jews secretly engineer demographic replacement

The antisemitic version of “Great Replacement” imagines Jews orchestrating immigration to destroy another population. It turns migrants and Jews alike into targets of conspiracy.

Source: AJC · Great Replacement

Back to categories ↑
Jews cause every war and crisis

A hidden Jewish hand becomes the explanation regardless of the evidence. Real decisions by named institutions and governments disappear into collective blame.

Source: ADL · Power

Back to categories ↑
Jews control the weather

The conspiracy grants Jews fantastic technological powers and blames them for disasters. It is a modern variation on the idea of an all-powerful hidden enemy.

Source: ADL · Power

Back to categories ↑

Loyalty & belonging

Jewish citizens are foreign agents

Jewish identity is treated as evidence of divided allegiance before any conduct is examined. A specific conflict of interest can be investigated; Jewishness is not itself a conflict of interest.

Source: ADL · Disloyalty

Back to categories ↑
The stab-in-the-back myth

After Germany’s First World War defeat, antisemites falsely blamed Jews for betraying Germany from within. Military defeat was recast as ethnic treachery.

Source: ADL · Disloyalty

Back to categories ↑
Jews are collectively responsible for communism

The involvement of some Jews in revolutionary movements does not make all Jews responsible for a political system. The accusation ignores Jewish political diversity and its Jewish victims.

Source: ADL · Disloyalty

Back to categories ↑
Today’s Jews are not the “real Jews”

Identity-denial narratives erase living Jewish communities and their history. This is different from studying ancestry or religious conversion: the trope uses a fabricated replacement story to delegitimise Jews.

Source: AJC · Not the real Jews

Back to categories ↑

Religious myths

Jews collectively killed Jesus

The charge imposes inherited guilt on an entire people. Jesus was executed under Roman authority; Nostra aetate rejected collective Jewish responsibility in 1965.

Source: ADL · Deicide

Back to categories ↑
Blood libel

The false accusation that Jews murder non-Jewish children for religious rituals has repeatedly fuelled persecution. Calling the story ancient does not make it evidence.

Source: USHMM · Blood libel

Back to categories ↑
Jews desecrate the consecrated host

Accusations of attacking the Eucharist turned Christian religious imagery into a pretext for violence against Jews. These were allegations of ritual evil, not evidence of collective practice.

Source: ADL · Deicide

Back to categories ↑
Jews poisoned the wells

During medieval epidemics, Jews were blamed for poisoning water. Scapegoating an identifiable minority supplied a culprit when people did not understand disease.

Source: USHMM · Blood libel

Back to categories ↑
Conversion can never make a Jew trustworthy

Some medieval Christians condemned Jews for refusing conversion while suspecting converts of insincerity. This double bind left no action that could satisfy the accusation.

Source: USHMM · Early Church to 1400

Back to categories ↑

Dehumanization & racial myths

Jews are vermin or animals

Animal imagery strips people of individuality and humanity. Antisemitic propaganda used such portrayals long before the Nazis and made exclusion and violence easier to justify.

Source: USHMM · 500 years of propaganda

Back to categories ↑
Jews are parasites on society

Nazi propaganda portrayed Jews as consuming and corrupting the societies in which they lived. It erased their ordinary human lives and contributions in favour of an imagined infestation.

Source: USHMM · Nazi propaganda

Back to categories ↑
Jewish blood contaminates others

Racial antisemites cast intermarriage as a biological threat. The premise was racist pseudoscience, not an account of human worth or biology.

Source: USHMM · Racial antisemitism

Back to categories ↑
Jews have an unchangeable sinister racial character

Racial antisemitism made conversion irrelevant by declaring hostile stereotypes inherited and permanent. No individual’s actions could disprove the supposed essence assigned to the group.

Source: USHMM · Racial antisemitism

Back to categories ↑

Holocaust denial & distortion

The Holocaust did not happen

Denial discards the converging evidence of documents, physical sites, testimony and perpetrators’ records. It is not the same as asking a good-faith historical question.

Source: USHMM · Holocaust denial

Back to categories ↑
There were no killing gas chambers

Denying the gas chambers is a recurring denial tactic. It attempts to remove a central part of the Nazi machinery of mass murder from the historical record.

Source: USHMM · Denial: key dates

Back to categories ↑
The deaths were only accidental wartime losses

Reducing genocide to disease and shortages erases deliberate killing and the policies that created lethal conditions. Wartime context does not turn intentional persecution into an accident.

Source: USHMM · Denial: key dates

Back to categories ↑
The Jewish death toll was invented

Denial often attacks the scale of murder to undermine the genocide itself. Responsible scholarship refines evidence; it does not begin by assuming a Jewish deception.

Source: USHMM · Denial: key dates

Back to categories ↑
Jews fabricated the Holocaust for money or Israel

This combines denial with the old conspiracy about Jewish power and greed. It claims victims and survivors invented their persecution for collective advantage.

Source: USHMM · Holocaust denial

Back to categories ↑

Israel-related collective blame

Connection is not a confession

Many Jews in the diaspora have a deep connection to Israel and are proud to support it, even when they question its government or don’t understand every decision. That connection isn’t something we need to apologize for. Ask me what I believe, challenge the views I actually hold, but don’t demand that I renounce Israel as the price of belonging.

Source: IHRA · Working definition

Back to categories ↑
Every Jewish citizen is loyal to Israel first

Assuming allegiance from Jewish identity revives the older foreign-agent accusation. Assess what someone actually does, not what ancestry is supposed to make them do.

Source: IHRA · Working definition

Back to categories ↑
“Zionists” secretly control everything

A change of label does not change a claim about an omnipotent hidden cabal. The word Zionist is not inherently a slur; the specific claim and context determine what is being said.

Source: IHRA · Working definition

Back to categories ↑
Jewish targets are fair game because of Israeli policy

Threats or attacks against Jews and Jewish institutions are not policy criticism. A political grievance cannot make collective punishment legitimate.

Source: IHRA · Working definition

Back to categories ↑

Political and legal claims are a different category.

Criticism of Israel, its government, military operations, settlements or laws is not automatically antisemitic. A legal allegation needs legal evidence; a political argument needs an answer. Neither is settled by putting it on a list of prejudices.

The boundary matters: argue about a policy or an institution, not an imagined Jewish character. Collective blame, threats against Jewish people and recycled conspiracy myths do not become acceptable because the argument mentions Israel.

Zionism, racism and national self-determination

My Zionism is Jewish self-determination. I do not accept that the desire for a Jewish homeland is inherently racist. But that conviction does not settle every question about what a state does.

Arab citizens of Israel vote and serve in public life. Palestinians living under occupation have a different legal and political position. Pointing to the first does not answer every allegation about the second. The ICJ's July 2024 advisory opinion found a breach of Article 3 of the Convention on racial discrimination in the occupied territory; that article addresses racial segregation and apartheid.

Argue with the evidence and the legal reasoning. Distinguish the territory, the policy, and the people affected. I object when a serious allegation becomes a slogan that renders Jewish self-determination itself illegitimate. I also owe the reader more than a slogan in reply.

IHRA definition and its qualification on criticism of Israel

Apartheid, occupation and discrimination

These terms make claims about institutions and law. Specify the territory, population, policy and legal standard. The ICJ’s July 2024 advisory opinion found a breach of Article 3 of the racial discrimination convention in the occupied Palestinian territory. An advisory opinion is not a criminal conviction; its reasoning should be read rather than reduced to a slogan.

ICJ · July 2024 advisory opinion summary

The IHRA working definition is non-legally binding and explicitly distinguishes comparable criticism of Israel from antisemitism. It is a reference point here, not a replacement for examining context.

Jewish tropes / Israel rhetoric / the connecting thread

Different vocabulary.
Familiar machinery.

Sometimes an old accusation gets a new political label. Follow the idea, not just the word. Here is one documented borrowing and three patterns to recognize.

Secret power

A hidden Jewish hand runs the world.

The forged Protocols of the Elders of Zion packaged a conspiracy as a secret plan.

Import the conspiracy into a national conflict
Documented borrowing · 1988

The same forgery. Named outright.

Article 32 of Hamas’s founding covenant invokes the Protocols as evidence of a Zionist expansion plan.

The receipts + the distinction

This is not a resemblance we have guessed at: the document names the forgery. Read Hamas’s 1988 covenant, Article 32, alongside the US Holocaust Memorial Museum’s history of the forgery.

Date matters: Hamas’s 2017 political document used different language and distinguished Jews from Zionists. That does not erase what its 1988 covenant said. Investigating a named lobby’s documented activity is not the same as alleging a hidden Jewish world government.

Dual loyalty

A Jew can never really belong here.

Jewish identity itself becomes supposed evidence of disloyalty.

Turn connection into presumed treason
Illustrative pattern · not a quotation

Jewish, therefore an agent of Israel.

A Jewish citizen’s judgment is dismissed before their conduct is examined.

The receipts + the distinction

ADL traces the disloyalty accusation. The Nexus Document identifies presumptions about Jews’ inability to set aside loyalty to Israel as antisemitic. A real conflict of interest requires evidence about a person, not a conclusion drawn from being Jewish.

Collective guilt

Make every Jew answer for the group.

Individual people disappear into an imagined single actor.

Replace responsibility with identity
Illustrative pattern · not a quotation

Israel did it. Your Jewish neighbor owes you an answer.

Being Jewish becomes enough to assign blame for a government’s actions.

The receipts + the distinction

The Nexus Document identifies presumed culpability imposed on Jewish people or institutions for Israel’s conduct. Challenge what someone actually supports. Pride in Israel is not shameful, and it does not make every Jew responsible for every Israeli decision.

Blood libel

Jewish religion demands innocent blood.

The historic lie accused Jews of killing non-Jews for ritual purposes.

Turn an allegation of harm into a myth of Jewish nature
Illustrative pattern · not a quotation

Bloodthirst as a Jewish trait.

Ritual-blood imagery or claims of an inherently murderous Jewish faith move from conduct to demonization.

The receipts + the distinction

ADL’s history of the blood libel explains the ritual-murder myth and its later uses. An allegation that a military killed children is not, by itself, blood libel. Examine the evidence for the incident; examine the imagery and language before making the historical comparison.

Changing “Jew” to “Zionist” is not a magic eraser. If the argument still depends on Jewish conspiracy, inherited guilt or inherent evil, changing the noun does not fix it.

Nor is every criticism of Israel a Jewish trope. Genocide, apartheid and colonialism allegations must be tested against facts and definitions, not classified by keyword. These arrows map rhetorical mechanisms, not a claim that every speaker inherited an ideology. Read the distinction.

Israel tropes & claims / 14 entries

The accusation.
The history left out.
The receipts.

You don’t have to invent every fact to sell a false story. Sometimes you just leave out the facts that would ruin it.

02

“Colonialist” is not a substitute for history.

The Jewish connection to the land predates the British Mandate; Britain didn’t invent it. The history includes migration, competing national movements, British rule and war. Calling Jews foreign to Judea doesn’t make that history disappear.

Source: U.S. Office of the Historian

04

David and Goliath depends on where you point the camera.

Frame Israel against Gaza alone and you tell one story. Include the regional wars, armed groups and threats against Israel and you begin to see why Israelis don’t experience themselves as invulnerable. In 1948, armies from neighboring Arab states entered the former Mandate after Israel declared independence.

Source: U.S. Office of the Historian

06

Genocide is not a slogan.

It’s a grave allegation with a legal definition, including specific intent to destroy a protected group in whole or in part. Population growth alone doesn’t settle it, and neither does a casualty figure alone. A serious defense should confront the evidence and legal standard.

Source: UN definition

07

One word cannot replace a map.

Israel, the West Bank, East Jerusalem and Gaza do not all have the same legal arrangements. Nor does the Palestinian Authority simply govern the entire West Bank. The 2024 ICJ advisory opinion made findings about Israeli policies of separation in the occupied territory; a response has to address those actual findings, not a weaker version.

Source: ICJ summary

08

Antisemitism doesn’t become progressive when it changes vocabulary.

Hamas’s 1988 covenant includes a passage about killing Jews and conspiracy claims about Jewish power. Those are not criticisms of a government. Name the movement and show readers its words.

Source: 1988 covenant

09

Civilian victims were not a footnote to October 7.

Hamas’s account sought to deny deliberately targeting civilians. Human Rights Watch concluded that killing civilians and taking hostages were planned objectives, not merely unauthorized mistakes. Soldiers were killed too; that does not excuse the murder of civilians.

Source: HRW investigation

10

The documented atrocities don’t need embellishment.

Investigators documented killings, attacks on families, homes set on fire and abuse of bodies. HRW described attackers burning homes to kill occupants or force them outside. The evidence is horrific enough without turning every early report into established fact.

Sources: UN findings · HRW

11

Jewish displacement belongs in the story too.

A history of the region’s refugees that leaves out persecuted and displaced Jewish communities is incomplete. Iraqi Jewish history includes the 1941 Farhud and subsequent persecution and restrictions. These histories deserve to be told country by country.

Source: U.S. National Archives

12

Nazareth: show the numbers, not a convenient myth.

The Christian share of Nazareth’s population declined substantially, but the 80% starting figure needs a reliable source and date. A scholarly table records roughly two-thirds Christian in 1922 and a Muslim majority by 2005, while the absolute Christian population increased. Nazareth is in Israel, so those numbers don’t establish that Palestinian authorities expelled its Christians.

Source: Demographic study

13

Nakba and Shoah: similar translations, different histories.

Nakba means catastrophe and refers to Palestinian displacement associated with 1948; Shoah is the Hebrew term for the Holocaust. A shared translation doesn’t make them the same event. When someone makes a false equivalence, challenge the comparison itself.

Sources: UN: Nakba · USHMM: the Holocaust