
A people.
A home.
A future.

Photograph sources & credits
Original photographic pixels, with background areas hidden by a collage mask; no AI reconstruction. Golda Meir: Marion S. Trikosko, 1973, Library of Congress, public-domain source. Henrietta Szold: Alexander Ganan, 1940, National Library of Israel, source, CC BY 3.0; background clipped. Historical figures are not presented as endorsers of this essay.UNCURIOUS · 05
Why Israel Matters — Beyond the Political
There is a version of this argument that is purely political. Israel as safe haven. Israel as military power. Israel as the answer to statelessness. That version is true and we've covered it. But it misses the thing that can't be explained to someone who doesn't already feel it — and if you're Jewish and you're reading this, you feel it.
Jerusalem is not just a metaphor in Jewish prayer. It is a direction. Generations of Jews have turned towards it, carried it in the liturgy, and imagined returning. That is not merely a political position. It is a posture of the body that became a posture of the soul.
The laws of Judaism are built around the land. Shmita — the sabbatical year when the land rests. The Jubilee year. The corner of the field left for the poor. These are not abstract commandments. They are laws written for a specific geography, waiting to be fully practiced in the place they were designed for. We have been practicing an incomplete Judaism in exile, and we have always known it.
There is a tradition of leaving a small part of a home unfinished. Not because we forgot. Because we remember. We break a glass at weddings — a tradition so well known that non-Jews recognize it without knowing why — to say that even in our happiest moment, our joy is not complete. Not until we are home. Not until the Temple is restored. We are the only people in the world who have built mourning into their celebrations and called it tradition.
Jews kiss the ground when they land at Ben Gurion airport. I have seen grown men do it. I understand it completely. Because it is not just a country. It is the place that has been in the mouth of every prayer, in the break of every glass, in the unpainted corner of every Jewish home, in the bones of every Jew who has ever lived — whether they knew it or not.
And now they want to take it from us. Or convince us it was never ours. Or shame us for loving it.
The people who hate us do not get to define why we love Israel. Although lately — and I want to be honest about this — out of fear as well. Fear for our communities. Fear for our children. Fear for ourselves. Fear that what we learned about what happened to our grandparents' generation was not a storybook with a lesson at the end but a pattern that repeats. We were dumbfounded, growing up, how things could have gotten so bad so fast. How our people could have become lambs to the slaughter without reacting sooner. And now we are watching, in real time, the early chapters of something that has a familiar shape. This time we know how that story can end. And at least — at least — we have an Israel. Strong. Armed. Its door open. A place that cannot legally turn a Jew away. We have seen it go that bad before. We are not naive enough to think it can't go that bad again. But this time we are not without a home to run to.
That is why Israel matters. Not just as a country. As an insurance policy written in prayer and paid for in blood across three thousand years. As the place that makes the broken glass at the wedding not just a memory of loss but a promise of return.
They can have the argument. We'll keep the glass.
And through all of it — the ingathering, the building, the fighting, the flourishing — I don't think we can be honest about our success without being honest about where it came from. I'm not shy about this. G-d is with me in every step I take. Not as a concept, not as a metaphor, but as a presence I feel when I pray, when I study, when I watch my children grow, and yes — conspicuously absent when I lose my temper on the highway or raise my voice at the wrong moment, because I am also human, which He apparently knew when He made me. The point is that when a people as small as ours, as scattered and traumatized and fractious as ours, manages to do what we have done — come home, build a country, win wars we had no business winning, produce a disproportionate share of the world's science and art and law and medicine — the intellectually honest response isn't pride alone. It's gratitude. And I fear, genuinely fear, that one of the costs of our success is that we have let G-d consciousness slip from the center of who we are as a people. That we have outsourced the question of Jewish identity to institutions and federations and think tanks, when it was always meant to live in the home, in the kitchen, in the daily practice of remembering who you are and why it matters. When we forget that, history has a way of reminding us. Violently.
The Torah Is Not a Trophy — It's a Mirror
There is something else that sets us apart from every other people with a sacred text, and it is this: ours doesn't flatter us. Our protagonists lie, scheme, doubt, and fail. Our greatest king is an adulterer who sends a man to his death to cover it. Our lawgiver loses his temper and doesn't make it to the promised land. Our patriarchs are complicated men doing their imperfect best in impossible circumstances. The Torah is not a book of ideal humans to admire and emulate. It is a book that doesn't allow us to rest on our laurels. It forces us to face our shortcomings. It is, in the most honest reading, largely a book about what not to do — and then what to do next, which is always the same thing: repent, keep your faith, forge forward.
The uncurious reach into this text to condemn us. They think they've found an indictment. And I want to be precise about why I call them the uncurious rather than our enemies — because they are only our enemies by their own choosing, not ours. Had they bothered to ask questions, to learn about us from something other than the weak and paranoid who are satisfied with superficial explanations, who scapegoat us rather than look within themselves, and who project that outward to the world for fame and egotistical glory — had they done any of that, they would not hate us. They would not see us as their enemies at all. Calling them our enemies implies we have something against them. We don't. We only have something against them because they have chosen, without justifiable or rational cause, to see us as theirs. What they have actually found is the whole point: a text that demands we examine our failures. But because of their ideological blinders they miss what is squarely in front of them. They have invented different filters for viewing the same text, and because they aren't us, they egotistically attribute what they find there as an eternal admonishment — proof of our guilt, our violence, our unworthiness. Whereas we have no choice but to see it simply as a lesson in what not to do, and forge forward. Eternally forward. Until this earthly experiment bears its eternal, sweet, savory, nourishing, sublime fruit.
It is the book that doesn't allow us to rest on our laurels that forces us to stick our necks above the parapet. Yes, one could say that our forefathers were imperfect — so what chance do we have? The uncurious think that's what we're thinking. It's actually the opposite. It says that despite not always getting it right, we always strive to be better. And while other traditions preach about G-d's grace, we believe in it so wholeheartedly that we show our weaknesses — because our faith is mirrored by the Almighty's faith in us, despite our mistakes.
When your collective narrative is that G-d spoke to us — to us, directly, in history, in covenant — you don't go silently into that good night because you failed. You repent. You keep your faith. No matter how many find you strange or threatening or even evil. We, like Abraham — who once he understood the truth of the one G-d, and knew Him to be Good everlasting, could not divorce it — we cannot divorce it either. Even when, often, it feels like He has divorced us.
October 7
And so it did. October 7, 2023 was a horror. I won't dress it up. What happened that morning was the kind of thing that breaks people permanently, and for many families it did exactly that. But something else happened alongside the grief, something I don't think is morbid to name even if it feels that way at first — it woke us up. Not just in Israel. Everywhere. The Jew who had spent years quietly managing his identity, keeping it tasteful, not making too much noise — that Jew looked at the images from the Nova festival and the kibbutzim and felt something shift in his bones. Being Jewish stopped being something you were and became something worth fighting for. A new kind of Jew emerged from that morning. Not new in history — we've been this Jew before, we know him well — but new in living memory. A Jew who is done apologizing for existing. Done explaining. Done performing reasonableness for audiences that have already decided the verdict. If there's a template for what comes next, October 7 is where it started. In the most brutal and unwanted way imaginable, G-d shook us. And we are still deciding what to do with the shaking.
The Unique Sickness — On Antisemitism
Antisemitism is not like other forms of bigotry, and it's worth being precise about why. Most prejudice is about fear of the other, competition for resources, cultural friction. Antisemitism does something different. It constructs a complete theology of evil around one people. It says: if there is one group responsible for all the world's suffering, then hating them isn't bigotry — it's a moral obligation. You're not a racist. You're a benefactor of humanity. And if a few of them turn out to be decent people, well, that's the cost of generalizing, and surely G-d will forgive you for it given the magnitude of the service you're rendering. This is how evil these people are — evil enough to justify the prejudice, evil enough to make the prejudice feel righteous.
There is no other form of racism this architecturally complete. It provides its believers with an enemy, a mission, a community of the righteous, and a divine cover story — all in one package. And it is almost impossible to shake once it takes root, especially when it's planted in childhood, when you've been told from the beginning that yes, the world is unfair and confusing and hard, but at least you know why. At least you can name it. At least you're smart enough not to be fooled. The Jew is a gift to the conspiratorial mind because the Jew makes the chaos of the world feel legible.
And then they do hafuch al hafuch — invert the inverted. A common accusation is that we believe we are chosen, and therefore can do whatever we want, kill whoever we want, erase whoever we want, with G-d's protection and impunity. The uncurious find this convincing because it sounds like something a supremacist would believe. What they don't understand — because they haven't asked, because they're uncurious — is what chosenness actually means to us. As one comedian put it, being the chosen people is like being the teacher's special little helper, who has the privilege of helping her clean up the classroom at the end of the day. It is not a license. It is more homework.
Our story is that we chose G-d and G-d chose us. Once you see G-d, you can't unsee Him. And if He comes and speaks to you, and gives you an instruction book, you follow it as best you can. The same book, by the way, that the two other religions who seem to have the biggest problem with us also believe in and claim authority over. And yet somehow we're the ones to blame for it.
My own philosophy is simpler than any of this. G-d is not beholden to me. He doesn't explain Himself. It is not my job to demand that He does. He gave us a book, and we follow it as best we can. What He has for other people around the world — what He communicated through Muhammad, through Jesus, through Buddha, through Lao Tzu, through, why not, Albert Einstein — is interesting, and none of my business. The world is His playground, not mine. I'm not competing for favorite child status here. Well — maybe I am, a little. But it doesn't mean my brothers and sisters of other faiths are evil or unworthy of His love. To me, the Torah is a gift. It is the best way I know to express my appreciation for G-d and for the gift of life. And I don't go deeper than that, because I don't need to.
I've held onto something since a Religious Studies class in my early twenties — a Jainist idea that any sincere path to G-d is a direct path. Whatever brings you genuinely closer to Him, nobody can judge. I've never found a reason to let go of that. It makes me a worse supremacist but a better Jew.
And if I'm being fully honest about why this project exists — underneath the history, the arguments, the diagnosis of antisemitism, the exhaustion of explaining — it's this: I hope people find their way to G-d. Whatever path gets them there. That's why we're all here anyway. The covenant isn't a trophy. It's an obligation we carry so the world can eventually benefit from it. We don't want your defeat. We want your flourishing. Find G-d. Any path. Go.
That is not weakness after everything I've written. That is the whole point. That clarity is itself a kind of grace.
The project is named for the uncurious, but it is written for us. For the people tired of explaining themselves to an audience that arrived with its verdict. I don't want us to borrow that habit. Our own claims have to survive questions too.
The Israeli Jew — Version 2.0
There is something you notice immediately about Israeli Jews that takes a diaspora Jew a moment to process. They are sunkissed and strong — mentally and physically. They carry themselves differently. They are already living the answer to the question the rest of us are still asking: what does it mean to live a fully Jewish life unencumbered by the need to make space for a suspicious majority?
The Israeli Jew doesn't have to prove himself to a wider community. He is the wider community. He has trudged the swamps. He has made accommodations for the other when possible and put them in their place when they look askance. He fights back. He gets in your face if need be to make clear that your intentions had better be focused on your own business and not his. This is not aggression for its own sake. It is the posture of a people who learned, across two thousand years of diaspora, that excessive deference gets you killed — and who have finally, in one small sliver of land, decided they are done being deferential.
To a Western mindset this can read as rudeness. Israelis can seem blunt to the point of abrasion, impatient, occasionally insufferable. If you've spent any time there you know what I mean. But there is something underneath the callousness that is worth understanding: to make it in Israel, you have to have your head on a swivel. The country is small and the neighborhood is hostile and you genuinely cannot always know if the Arab neighbor who has been your friend for twenty years will suddenly become your enemy. History has shown it happens. That vigilance costs something. It puts callouses on the heart alongside the hands. And the miracle — the part that doesn't get said — is that despite the very existential angst the whole country lives with, despite a hundred years of being attacked from every direction, despite October 7, there is any sensitivity to the human condition at all. That they aren't complete assholes around the clock is itself remarkable, even if to visiting Western eyes it sometimes appears they are.
This is also the place to recognise Arab and Palestinian citizens of Israel as people with their own experiences. They vote, build businesses, work as doctors and judges, and serve in parliament. Their citizenship matters. So do the inequalities and tensions they describe.
I cannot tell them what belonging feels like from inside their lives. I can say what I expect of the country I love: dignity and equal citizenship cannot depend on being Jewish. A democracy is tested by what happens when the majority feels frightened, not only when everyone feels safe.
The Chicken and the Egg — Who Started What
Security is not an abstraction
What disappears too often from the argument is the fear behind Israeli decisions. Buses, cafés, schools, homes. People remember where they were. Security measures did not emerge from nowhere.
Checkpoints and barriers can protect people and impose severe burdens on others. Both can be true. Recognising the security purpose does not exempt every measure from scrutiny. Ignoring the attacks that helped produce it does not amount to scrutiny either.
The conflict also predates Israel's capture of the West Bank and Gaza in 1967. That history matters. It does not erase the separate questions of rights, occupation, and what happens next.
A soldier's fear is real. So is a civilian's vulnerability. Understanding the first cannot become a blanket excuse for abusing the second. I want people to understand what Israelis carry, without pretending that carrying it makes every decision right.
What I reject is the refusal to recognise Jewish sovereignty while demanding recognition for Palestinian sovereignty. That refusal exists, most starkly in Hamas's position. It is not the position of every Palestinian, and the PLO's formal recognition of Israel belongs in an honest account.
Online, that distinction often disappears. An entire people becomes a villain or a symbol. A response is shown without the event that preceded it. A civilian death becomes a point scored. The story travels faster than anyone's curiosity.
The next essay records attacks that shaped Israeli life. It is one part of the history, not a licence to disregard anyone else's suffering. Read it with this question in mind: what would living through that history do to your sense of safety?